Retail investors can soon invest in startups and other ventures. No longer are such opportunities available only for the wealthy (so called “accredited”) investors. This is the JOBS Act Title III coming into effect in the US. Such a change will benefit equity and real estate crowdfunding platforms the most. Investors will also benefit from greater access to investment opportunities; but investor education remains key. What about Singapore? Currently regulations still prohibit retail investors from fully participating in equity and real estate crowdfunding. But the world is changing and we need to change too…
MAY 13, 20167:44 PM
[SAN FRANCISCO] New crowdfunding rules taking effect Monday will allow anyone to invest in startups-not just wealthy people.
The change overrides a longstanding Securities and Exchange Commission requirement that investors backing private companies be “accredited,” meaning they make at least US$200,000 a year and have a net worth of US$1 million or more (excluding their home).
Now startups raising money through online crowdfunding portals will be able to sell shares to people regardless of their wealth or income so long as the founders have submitted annual financial reports to the SEC. In exchange, companies can raise up to US$1 million.
The rules, implemented as part of Title III of the JOBS Act, were four years in the making and the result of industry lobbying to make the process more democratic. The big question is how much the change will transform crowdfunding, which has typically rewarded backers with T-shirts, events tickets and early iterations of gadgets.
While some startups are keen to sell shares to small investors, others are hanging back because they find the rules too onerous and the fundraising limit too low. Meanwhile, Kickstarter, the biggest and best-known crowdfunding site, has no plans to join the party. As a result, regular folk hoping to get in on the next Uber or Airbnb may be disappointed.
It’s early days but non-tech entrepreneurs who have trouble attracting venture capital are considered the most likely to take advantage of the option. People like Tom Lix, who’s keen to raise US$1 million on the Wefunder portal so he can expand his Cleveland liquor startup.
“I would love for my customers to be my shareholders,” says Mr Lix, whose Cleveland Whiskey LLC says it can age whiskey in 24 hours. “I couldn’t ask for better fans.”
Richard Swart, a founding board member of the Crowdfunding Professional Association, says the new fundraising rules could especially appeal to companies outside venture-capital rich California and New York. He says entrepreneurs in theater, food production and energy have expressed the most interest so far, along with minority-led businesses.
“We’re hoping crowdfunding can start to equalize the distribution of funding,” says Mr Swart, who also serves as chief strategy officer at NextGen Crowdfunding LLC, a year-old startup that provides information about funding portals, individual companies and crowdfunding regulations.
Still, he and others acknowledge that new funding option could have limited appeal. Jim Fulton, an attorney at Cooley LLP who specializes in corporate and securities law for emerging companies, says many companies, especially in tech, consider the US$1 million limit too low and the costs to register and submit annual results too high. He says fewer than a dozen clients have asked about the option. Another potential turnoff: a requirement that companies communicate with investors as individuals rather than as a group.
“If you’re not going to raise US$5 million,” Mr Fulton says, “I don’t know why you’d subject yourself to this burden.”
The costs vary depending on a company’s complexity and how much it wants to raise. Cleveland Whiskey expects to pay between US$40,000 and US$50,000 to raise US$1 million while Anikona Farm, which operates a coffee plantation in Hawaii, expects to pay between US$1,000 and US$20,000 to raise roughly US$100,000, according to owners at each company.
As of Thursday, five crowdfunding portals had been approved: Wefunder Portal LLC, SI Portal LLC, Seedinvest.com, CFS LLC, CrowdFundingSTAR.com, NextSeed US LLC and StartEngine Capital LLC. Three dozen more are awaiting approval.
A spokesman for Kickstarter said the company has no intention of adding equity investing to its platform. But rival crowdfunding portal Indiegogo does.
“It was the original goal of the founders when we launched in 2008 and it still is,” says Indiegogo Chief Executive David Mandelbrot, adding the company is working out details with attorneys now and expects to launch something later this year.
“Limiting venture financing to accredited investors and treating people differently according to their wealth feels very undemocratic. It’s sad it’s taken this long to change that, but at least these are steps in the right direction.”